These scorecards are a guide rating, not an absolute truth. They are designed to give you a quick, honest read on each app before a conversation with your child or before you set up a new device. Treat them as a starting point for thinking, not as the final word.
Every card scores an app across nine categories. Four are risk metrics — stranger contact, location sharing, in-app spending and harmful content. For these, green means low risk and red means a known, well-documented problem area. Three are strength metrics— how good the platform's moderation is, how useful its parental controls are, and how easy it is to report something when it goes wrong. For these, the colours are inverted: green means the safeguards are genuinely strong, and red means weak or close to absent. One category, age suitability, gives both the minimum age at which the app is technically usable and the age at which we would actually feel comfortable suggesting it to a UK family. The final category, prevalence at school, simply tells you how likely it is that your child's classmates already use the app — useful context if you are weighing up a no for now.
A few important caveats. First, apps change. A scorecard accurate in May 2026 may shift after the next update, especially as the Online Safety Act's child safety duties continue to bed in. We review every card at least quarterly and the date is shown on each card. Second, your child is unique. A fifteen-year-old with strong digital habits and a trusted adult to talk to can manage a high-risk app better than an eleven-year-old without those things. Always weigh the scorecard against your own child, their maturity, and what their friends are doing. Third, official age ratings still matter. PEGI, BBFC and the platforms' own minimum ages reflect legal and commercial decisions that sit on top of our guidance. If an app says 13+, we cannot lower that even when we think 15 is a more realistic age.
A suggested workflow. Skim the scorecard for the app you are weighing up. Click through to the full guide for the same app — every name links across. Set up the parental controls the guide recommends before your child opens the app for the first time. Have one short, honest conversation about the two highest-risk areas on the card. Then put a reminder in your phone to come back in three months: apps change, your child grows up, and what was the right setting in May will not necessarily be the right setting in August.
Finally, no scorecard replaces the basics. A child who knows they can tell you anything, without being shouted at, is safer on a red-risk app than a child who has been locked out of a green one. The scorecards exist to support that conversation, not to replace it.